- Not Appealing the Denial at All
- Insufficient Medical Evidence and Gaps in Treatment
- Earning Too Much While Appealing
- Not Working With a Disability Attorney
When serious health problems interfere with your ability to work, Social Security Disability benefits can be a financial lifeline. Many Wisconsin residents apply believing their medical condition clearly qualifies—only to receive a denial letter from the Social Security Administration (SSA).
If that’s where you are now, you’re not alone. Appealing a denial can feel overwhelming, but avoiding common mistakes can significantly improve your chances of success. At Hein Law Office, we help clients navigate Wisconsin Social Security Disability claims every day.
Below are some of the most frequent mistakes people make during the appeal process—and how you can avoid them.
Mistake #1: Not Appealing the Denial at All
One of the biggest mistakes is giving up after the initial denial. Many applicants assume a denial means they are not eligible. In reality, a large number of claims are denied simply due to missing paperwork, incomplete medical evidence, or technical issues.
Appealing gives you another opportunity to correct those issues. In many cases, claimants are approved at later stages—especially when proper documentation and legal arguments are presented.
Always appeal. You may be much closer to approval than you think.
Mistakes #2 and #3: Insufficient Medical Evidence and Gaps in Treatment
Not Submitting Enough Medical Evidence
When you appeal, SSA expects stronger and more detailed proof. This typically includes:
- Medical records and treatment notes
- Diagnostic test results
- Prescription history
- Statements from treating physicians
- Documentation showing functional limitations
Failing to provide thorough evidence can lead to another denial.
Not Continuing Medical Treatment
SSA may question the severity of your condition if you are not actively seeking medical care. Regular treatment creates the paper trail needed to support your claim. Even if finances or fatigue make appointments difficult, consistent care is critical to a successful appeal.
Mistake #4: Earning Too Much While Appealing
If you are working and earning more than SSA’s limit for “substantial gainful activity,” your claim may be denied—regardless of your medical condition.
While limited work may sometimes be necessary to survive financially, working too much can signal to SSA that you are capable of employment. A disability attorney can help you understand what level of work may jeopardize your appeal.
Mistake #5: Not Working With a Disability Attorney
Appeals are far more complex than initial applications. You may need to:
- Prepare testimony for a hearing
- Question vocational or medical experts
- Identify legal errors in SSA decisions
- Present persuasive legal arguments
Attempting this alone puts you at a disadvantage. Working with an experienced attorney—especially after a denial—can dramatically improve your odds.
If you’re unsure about timing, Hein Law Office explains When to Hire a Social Security Disability Attorney and why early legal guidance matters.
Get Help With Wisconsin Social Security Disability Appeals
If you’ve been denied benefits, it doesn’t mean your case is over. Hein Law Office assists clients across Wisconsin with Wisconsin Social Security Disability claims, from early appeals to hearings before an administrative law judge.
Having the right legal support can make the difference between another denial and the benefits you need to move forward.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do I have to appeal a Social Security Disability denial in Wisconsin?
You generally have 60 days from the date you receive your denial notice to file an appeal.
Can I appeal a disability denial without a lawyer?
Yes, but appeals are legally and procedurally complex. Claimants represented by attorneys often have higher success rates.
What happens if I miss the appeal deadline?
Missing the deadline may require starting the application process over unless you can show good cause for the delay.
What if I was denied more than once?
Multiple denials are common. Each level of appeal offers a new opportunity to present stronger evidence and legal arguments.
Does it cost anything upfront to hire a disability attorney?
Most Social Security Disability attorneys work on contingency, meaning you pay nothing unless benefits are awarded.
Hein Law Office, LLC
